Breast Cancer Treatment - Doctor’s Dilemma or Patient’s Choice?

Published: 17th October 2018

A joint conference organised by The Latte Lounge, Pink Ribbon, Europa Donna and the Surgical Interventional Trials Unit, UCL The Royal Society, 6-9 Carlton House Terrace, SW1Y 5AG, 31st October

A groundbreaking women’s health conference is being held on Wednesday 31st October, during Breast Cancer Awareness Month, to address three key areas where women are often denied the information they need to make a shared decision with their doctors regarding their own health needs.

This conference has been planned by a group of eminent breast cancer specialists, in partnership with well-informed womens’ groups-  the Latte Lounge (Top tips for women over 40), the Pink Ribbon charity, and Europa Donna, the European Breast Cancer Coalition. The aim will be to  help women already diagnosed or at risk of developing breast cancer, to take a more active role in this partnership. We hope that women will come away with a better understanding of the cancer treatments available to them. 

Topics to be discussed will include:

  • Finding the balance between the benefits and harms around mammographic screening
  • Pros and Cons of hormone replacement therapy (HRT)
  • Intraoperative radiotherapy after breast conserving surgery /lumpectomy.

The most important demographic sub-group in modern society are women aged 40-65 - so often caught between bringing up children at the same time as worrying about their ageing parents - and often pursuing a career as well. Sometimes regarded as “The filling between two slices of bread”.

Women in this age group are also often entering their peri-menopausal years and going on to suffer the consequences of the menopause. As well as the climacteric syndrome, these women often have to cope with feelings of low self-esteem and depression. Because of the heavy burden they carry, they often put their own health needs to the bottom of the priority scale.

Breast cancer is also an important threat to this age group - both physical and psychological. These days it is considered essential for doctors to involve their patients in the decision-making process, but in truth, far too many doctors merely pay lip-service to this ideal.

We sympathise with both sides of this dialogue because the subject is so complex, so difficult to understand. Even experts themselves share many differences of opinion. What’s more, there is now an ethical and legal obligation to share these uncertainties with our patients when we are looking for informed consent before invasive diagnostic or therapeutic procedures. The patient must gently be made aware of the delicate trade-offs between improving length of life at the expense of quality of life (QOL) and patient reported outcomes (PROMS). Our obsessive focus on the threat of breast cancer means that few in the lay public know the good news - that breast cancer has slipped out of the top seven causes of death for women. Yet certain treatments for breast cancer might even increase the risk of treatment-induced mortality, particularly from cardio-vascular (heart and circulation) disorders and other cancers. For this reason, limitation of the lengthy traditional postoperative radiotherapy is emerging as a valuable means of reducing toxicity without compromising radiotherapy’s undoubted clinical effectiveness. A single treatment with targeted intraoperative radiotherapy under the same anasetheic as the definitive cancer operation has many benefits. This treatment, called TARGIT IORT, pioneered in UCL, has already been adopted in over 350 centres in 35 countries and over 20,000 women have been treated successfully.

Quite apart from this, many women in this age group are denied the undoubted benefits of HRT - the unjustified fear of breast cancer impairing both its cognitive and bone-strengthening benefits of HRT. In short, the totality of women’s overall health and quality of life must always come first.

Women must not be passive in their search for good health! Surely our patients should educate themselves more fully in order to properly participate as equal partners in the doctor-patient relationship.

This conference, timed to fall within “Breast Cancer Awareness Month”, hopes and intends to start the ball rolling. Book here.

Keynote Speakers:

  • Prof. Michael Baum (Prof. Emeritus of Surgery and visiting Prof.Medical Humanities, UCL) ) and Professor Antony Howell (Prof of Medical Oncology, University of Manchester, will be making the case for balancing the harms vs benefits of screening for breast cancer.
  • Dr. Avrum Bluming from Los Angeles, author of the book “Estrogen Matters” will be making the case that taking hormones in Menopause can improve Women’s Well-Being and lengthen their lives without raising the risk of breast cancer.


  • Prof Jayant S Vaidya (Professor of Surgery and Oncology at UCL) and Professor Frederik Wenz (Professor of Radiation Oncology, at University of Heidelberg, Mannheim, Germany) will be making the case for weeks of gruelling whole breast radiotherapy to be replaced by the NICE recommended approach of a single shot at the time of surgery. (TARGIT - Intra-operative radiotherapy).
  • Suzanne White, Partner and Head of Clinical Negligence, Leigh Day (a specialist law firm with some of the country's leading personal injury, product liability, clinical negligence, employment and discrimination, international and human rights teams) will describe the ethical and legal responsibility of doctors in the new era of shared decision making.

Panel of experts:

Professor Jeffrey S Tobias Profesor of Cancer Medicine, University College London.

Professor Michael Douek Professor of Surgical Oncology, Kings College London).

Dr Margaret Spittle OBE, Radiation Oncologist and Chairman of the UK forum of Europa Donna.

Katie Taylor, CEO & Founder The Latte Lounge.

Dr. Louise Newson Menopause Specialist GP and contributor on The Latte Lounge

Dr. Renee Hoenderkamp Women’s Health GP and resident Dr of The Latte Lounge.

Diane Danzebrink, The Menopause Support Network.

Marcelle Bernstein and Kirsty Lang, both prominent journalists (who have themselves had breast cancer) will be leading patients’ voices. 

For more information or to arrange an interview with any of the experts, please contact: Henry Killworth, UCL Media Relations, or 0207 679 5296.

Newson Health Menopause and Wellbeing Centre was founded by leading menopause specialist and GP, Dr Louise Newson, and officially opened in September 2018 by Liz Earle MBE. Created to help women receive the most appropriate, individualised treatment for their perimenopause and menopause, it has quickly become a centre of excellence, providing care to women of all ages, as well as running educational events for primary care clinicians.

Dr Newson is also the founder of the Menopause Doctor website, a free resource since 2017, providing the latest unbiased, evidence based information about the menopause and perimenopause for women as well as the most recent national and international menopause articles and guidelines for healthcare professionals. The website has been adopted by the Royal College of GPs (RCGP) as an official educational library aimed at patients and healthcare professionals wishing to learn more about the menopause.

Newson Health Research and Education is a not-for-profit organisation founded by Dr Newson, from which all profits gained from the organisation's activities, such as event sponsorship, delegate fees and speaker's fees, are invested back into the business.